Willie Mays card values

MAZIDEX tracks 414 Willie Mays cards with recorded sales. The most valuable is the 1951 Bowman #305 at about $16,350 in PSA 5, from 4 sales in the last 90 days. 100 cards have a current value. Values come from completed sales only, grade by grade, never from asking prices.

Most valuable Willie Mays cards

CardGradeValueTypical rangeSales, 90 days
1951 Bowman #305PSA 5$16,350$15,550–$17,8254
1952 Topps #261PSA 4$10,750$9,900–$13,1244
1967 Topps #200PSA 9$8,915$7,618–$10,2113
1970 Topps #600PSA 9$5,400$5,300–$5,7003
1966 Topps #1PSA 8$3,612$3,556–$4,1063
1963 Topps #300PSA 8$2,194$2,127–$2,2896
1961 Topps #150PSA 8$1,999$1,261–$2,0183
1965 Topps #250PSA 8$1,850$1,831–$1,8884
1954 Topps #90PSA 6$1,608$1,578–$1,9234
1957 Topps #10PSA 7$1,451$1,279–$1,8505
1972 Topps #49PSA 9$1,388$1,369–$1,4104
1963 Fleer #5PSA 8$1,195$1,173–$1,2753
1954 Bowman #89PSA 6$1,037$1,014–$1,0823
1959 Topps #50PSA 7$1,002$986.66–$1,0175
1956 Topps #130 Gray BackPSA 6$998.06$959.58–$1,0484
1969 Topps #190PSA 8$931.00$840.50–$1,0133
1962 Topps #300PSA 6$930.00$915.00–$950.003
1968 Topps #50PSA 8$875.88$766.38–$1,0526
1958 Topps #5PSA 6$839.50$785.00–$932.256
1960 Topps #200PSA 7$800.00$737.00–$847.005
1971 Topps #600PSA 7$625.00$585.85–$629.999
1955 Bowman #184PSA 4$482.50$445.75–$550.6010
1956 Topps #130 White BackPSA 3$425.00$417.88–$431.534
1964 Topps Giants #51PSA 8$391.51$382.51–$413.513
1973 Topps #305PSA 8$361.00$343.25–$397.0013
1964 Topps #150PSA 5$302.67$248.84–$351.333
1962 Topps #395 All StarPSA 7$229.00$214.50–$255.003
1968 Topps Game #8PSA 8$199.99$179.57–$210.003
2026 Topps Update Home Field #HA-48RAW$124.00$90.00–$130.0011
1972 Topps #50 In ActionPSA 7$100.00$86.00–$100.005

Each value is that grade's median daily sale price over the last 90 days; the typical range is the middle half of those days. A card shows its most valuable grade with a current value.

Willie Mays sets