1958 Topps card values

MAZIDEX tracks 525 1958 Topps cards with recorded sales. The most valuable is the Mickey Mantle #150 at about $5,850 in PSA 7, from 4 sales in the last 90 days. 436 cards have a current value. Values come from completed sales only, grade by grade, never from asking prices.

Most valuable 1958 Topps cards

CardGradeValueTypical rangeSales, 90 days
Mickey Mantle #150PSA 7$5,850$5,650–$6,2504
Mickey Mantle: All Star #487PSA 8$1,900$1,371–$2,1753
World Series Batting Foes #418PSA 6$1,099$977.50–$1,1007
Sandy Koufax #187PSA 7$889.50$876.00–$975.006
Willie Mays #5PSA 6$839.50$785.00–$932.256
Roger Maris #47PSA 6$700.00$647.50–$767.5012
Orlando Cepeda #343PSA 7$590.00$553.51–$728.503
Harmon Killebrew #288PSA 8$550.00$533.26–$562.503
Ted Williams #1PSA 5$424.95$387.50–$425.006
Hank Aaron #30 WhitePSA 4$353.00$334.29–$364.003
Yogi Berra #370PSA 6$325.00$231.31–$338.003
Pee Wee Reese #375PSA 8$300.00$283.01–$360.003
Ernie Banks #310PSA 6$286.00$284.00–$305.005
Hank Aaron #488 All StarPSA 6$255.00$208.75–$275.003
Ted Williams #485 All StarPSA 6$238.63$230.31–$246.943
Don Drysdale #25PSA 7$216.50$215.75–$303.253
Brooks Robinson #307PSA 6$215.00$215.00–$225.005
Larry Doby #424PSA 7$210.00$208.25–$241.003
Stan Musial #476 All StarPSA 7$187.50$159.40–$226.8812
Warren Spahn #270PSA 6$171.50$152.13–$189.254
Frank Robinson #285PSA 6$167.00$162.22–$179.254
Whitey Ford #320PSA 6$157.00$115.00–$160.005
Rival Fence Busters #436PSA 6$150.00$145.78–$152.253
Minnie Minoso #295PSA 7$147.50$117.25–$163.503
Bill Mazeroski #238PSA 7$147.25$144.57–$149.134
Bob Clemente #52 WhiteRAW$137.50$111.00–$165.005
Gil Hodges #162PSA 7$135.49$122.25–$136.683
Tony Kubek #393PSA 8$101.00$80.85–$124.503
Willie Mays #486 All StarPSA 3$100.00$95.25–$103.504
Eddie Mathews #480 All StarPSA 7$91.99$87.99–$94.994
Curt Flood #464PSA 6$84.00$80.73–$85.007
Frank Robinson #484 All StarPSA 6$83.25$78.62–$87.873
Nellie Fox #400PSA 7$82.51$80.25–$83.263
Dodgers Boss & Power #314PSA 7$79.00$74.01–$91.253
Vada Pinson #420PSA 5$75.00$70.00–$76.003
Ed Mathews #440PSA 5$62.00$61.50–$64.003
Jim Bunning #115PSA 7$60.48$54.70–$69.256
Red Schoendienst #190PSA 6$49.99$46.88–$62.503
Duke Snider #88SGC 5$48.00$43.50–$52.003
Al Walker #203PSA 8$47.50$42.75–$54.744
Ernie Banks #482 All StarPSA 4$47.50$45.00–$52.504
Gil McDougald #20 WhitePSA 7$41.00$40.52–$45.003
Carl Erskine #258PSA 6$40.00$35.50–$40.003
Billy Martin #271PSA 4$39.99$35.00–$42.493
Ernie Johnson #78 YellowRAW$35.50$24.38–$43.095
Mound Aces #334PSA 7$29.99$28.81–$31.503
Al Kaline #70 WhiteRAW$26.00$19.95–$35.1310
Sluggers Supreme #321RAW$25.00$18.50–$33.8827
Braves Fence Busters #351RAW$23.85$17.50–$29.8119
Hobie Landrith #24 YellowRAW$13.50$9.63–$19.754

Each value is that grade's median daily sale price over the last 90 days; the typical range is the middle half of those days. A card shows its most valuable grade with a current value.

Players in 1958 Topps