MAZIDEX

1958 Topps Willie Mays #5

1958 Topps · #5

What is the 1958 Topps Willie Mays #5 worth?

Estimated value in RAW: $94.00, typically $70.00–$169.75, from 67 recorded sales in the last 90 days; most recently Oct 31, 2026.

123 recorded sales in this grade in all, from $24.50 to $650.00.

Every price on this page is an actual recorded transaction, not an asking price. Raw and graded sales are kept separate, and each sale links to its receipt. How MAZIDEX values cards.

Updated with sales through Oct 31, 2026.

Recorded sales by grade

GradeRecorded salesFirst recordedMost recent
RAW123Jul 1, 2026Oct 31, 2026
PSA 447Jul 7, 2023Oct 30, 2026
PSA 335Feb 10, 2023Oct 30, 2026
PSA 532Nov 17, 2021Oct 31, 2026
PSA 727Feb 14, 2021Sep 20, 2026
PSA 626Mar 15, 2021Oct 18, 2026
PSA 225Jul 28, 2023Oct 3, 2026
PSA 825Jun 4, 2008Dec 11, 2025
PSA 1.511Nov 17, 2023Oct 31, 2026
SGC 410Jul 17, 2025Oct 29, 2026
SGC 39Jun 15, 2022Oct 29, 2026
SGC 79Feb 16, 2024Jul 14, 2026
SGC 4.58Jun 20, 2025Oct 20, 2026
SGC 56Oct 17, 2025Oct 26, 2026
PSA 15Jul 8, 2026Oct 29, 2026
SGC 1.55Jul 27, 2026Oct 21, 2026
SGC 2.54Aug 14, 2026Oct 21, 2026
PSA 3.54Jun 14, 2024Sep 18, 2026
PSA 4.54Jan 19, 2024Aug 2, 2025
SGC 3.53Mar 16, 2025Oct 26, 2026
SGC 63Oct 8, 2025Oct 14, 2026
SGC 5.53Aug 21, 2022Sep 16, 2026
SGC 6.53May 29, 2022Jul 22, 2026
SGC 83Feb 28, 2025Sep 28, 2025
BVG 73Nov 11, 2018Jun 25, 2023
BVG 83Oct 1, 2013Jul 18, 2016
SGC 12Aug 30, 2026Sep 3, 2026
PSA 2.52Jul 21, 2026Aug 20, 2026
SGC 22Aug 10, 2026Aug 15, 2026
BVG 4.52May 28, 2020Jun 29, 2025
CGC 12Aug 25, 2024Mar 10, 2025
BVG 5.52Jun 13, 2018Dec 30, 2023
BVG 42May 30, 2021Jul 15, 2021
CGC 71Jul 24, 2026Jul 24, 2026
CSG 4.51Jan 16, 2026Jan 16, 2026
CGC 3.51Apr 27, 2025Apr 27, 2025
SGC 7.51Mar 3, 2024Mar 3, 2024
BVG 31Oct 15, 2023Oct 15, 2023
BVG 61May 18, 2023May 18, 2023
CSG 3.51Aug 21, 2022Aug 21, 2022
BVG 2.51Oct 17, 2018Oct 17, 2018

Recent recorded sales · RAW

DatePriceGradeSource
Oct 31, 2026$45.00RAWeBay
Oct 30, 2026$195.00RAWeBay
Oct 29, 2026$34.11RAWeBay
Oct 29, 2026$78.01RAWeBay
Oct 24, 2026$69.00RAWeBay
Oct 24, 2026$152.50RAWeBay
Oct 24, 2026$30.99RAWeBay
Oct 23, 2026$152.50RAWeBay
Oct 21, 2026$70.00RAWeBay
Oct 20, 2026$54.66RAWeBay
Oct 19, 2026$275.00RAWeBay
Oct 18, 2026$49.99RAWeBay
Oct 18, 2026$90.00RAWeBay
Oct 17, 2026$80.00RAWeBay
Oct 17, 2026$41.00RAWeBay
Oct 15, 2026$79.94RAWeBay
Oct 14, 2026$135.00RAWeBay
Oct 12, 2026$36.00RAWeBay
Oct 11, 2026$120.00RAWeBay
Oct 11, 2026$54.00RAWeBay

Open the full price history and chart