Gary Carter card values

MAZIDEX tracks 132 Gary Carter cards with recorded sales. The most valuable is the 1976 Topps #441 All Star Rookie at about $209.52 in PSA 9, from 6 sales in the last 90 days. 44 cards have a current value. Values come from completed sales only, grade by grade, never from asking prices.

Most valuable Gary Carter cards

CardGradeValueTypical rangeSales, 90 days
1976 Topps #441 All Star RookiePSA 9$209.52$191.88–$246.256
1977 Topps #295PSA 9$180.70$153.03–$208.754
1978 Topps #120PSA 9$64.01$60.52–$66.254
1980 Topps #70PSA 9$63.02$57.01–$64.513
1984 Topps #450PSA 10$59.48$56.24–$59.744
1991 Topps #310PSA 10$42.49$38.01–$44.994
1981 Topps #660PSA 9$35.00$33.74–$36.244
1988 Topps #530PSA 10$31.00$25.75–$37.004
1979 Topps #520PSA 8$29.99$24.25–$32.493
1990 Topps #790PSA 10$27.08$22.79–$28.323
1993 Topps #205PSA 10$26.99$24.99–$35.005
1989 Bowman #379PSA 10$24.99$19.50–$24.995
1990 Donruss #147PSA 10$22.50$22.25–$22.503
1983 Donruss #340PSA 9$16.99$14.50–$17.443
1984 Topps #393PSA 9$16.75$15.87–$18.133
1983 Topps #370PSA 9$10.60$7.30–$17.783
2019 Topps Living #263RAW$5.01$4.30–$5.513
2015 Topps Heart of the Order #HOR-8RAW$1.92$1.59–$2.995
1986 Topps #170RAW$1.89$1.59–$1.994
1986 Topps #708RAW$1.79$1.64–$1.943
1989 Score #240RAW$1.77$1.51–$1.833
1985 Topps #230RAW$1.66$1.17–$1.7510
1993 Upper Deck #219RAW$1.59$0.99–$1.795
1989 Upper Deck #390RAW$1.53$1.22–$1.794
2025 Topps Chrome Platinum #482RAW$1.50$1.45–$1.736
2023 Panini Donruss #191 RedRAW$1.49$1.37–$1.993
2020 Topps Archives #46RAW$1.47$0.99–$3.114
1987 Topps #20RAW$1.43$1.03–$1.756
1990 Score #416RAW$1.38$1.00–$1.954
1982 Topps #730RAW$1.38$1.09–$1.876

Each value is that grade's median daily sale price over the last 90 days; the typical range is the middle half of those days. A card shows its most valuable grade with a current value.

Gary Carter sets