MAZIDEX

1958 Topps Willie Mays #486 All Star

1958 Topps · #486 · All Star

22 recorded sales in PSA 7, from $274.99 to $849.99, most recently Aug 13, 2026.

Every price on this page is an actual recorded transaction, not an asking price. Raw and graded sales are kept separate, and each sale links to its receipt. How MAZIDEX values cards.

Updated with sales through Aug 13, 2026.

Recorded sales by grade

GradeRecorded salesFirst recordedMost recent
PSA 722Apr 12, 2024Aug 13, 2026
RAW15Jul 9, 2026Sep 28, 2026
PSA 313Nov 11, 2025Sep 25, 2026
PSA 613Jul 21, 2021Sep 11, 2026
PSA 413Jul 7, 2023Aug 31, 2026
PSA 111Nov 17, 2023Aug 4, 2025
PSA 89May 20, 2020Jul 12, 2026
PSA 29Apr 2, 2025Jul 2, 2026
SGC 18Apr 22, 2024Jul 22, 2026
SGC 47Dec 1, 2023Oct 4, 2026
SGC 37Oct 22, 2025Sep 28, 2026
PSA 56Mar 8, 2024Sep 1, 2026
SGC 66Apr 30, 2025Aug 25, 2026
SGC 25Apr 30, 2025Jul 15, 2026
PSA 1.55Mar 31, 2024Apr 8, 2025
SGC 1.54May 9, 2024Apr 15, 2025
CGC 33Nov 2, 2025Oct 4, 2026
SGC 73Aug 9, 2024Sep 4, 2026
SGC 6.53Dec 16, 2025Aug 28, 2026
SGC 2.53Jul 10, 2025Nov 19, 2025
SGC 52Jul 2, 2026Aug 4, 2026
BVG 4.52Oct 15, 2023Jan 14, 2024
BVG 72Jul 10, 2018Feb 27, 2022
BVG 42Oct 14, 2019May 30, 2021
PSA 4.51Sep 14, 2026Sep 14, 2026
BGS 71Jul 8, 2026Jul 8, 2026
CGC 4.51Mar 1, 2026Mar 1, 2026
SGC 3.51Nov 8, 2025Nov 8, 2025
SGC 4.51Nov 5, 2025Nov 5, 2025
CGC 61Oct 3, 2025Oct 3, 2025
SGC 81Mar 22, 2025Mar 22, 2025
PSA 3.51Mar 15, 2024Mar 15, 2024
CSG 5.51Sep 18, 2022Sep 18, 2022
BVG 31Jun 29, 2021Jun 29, 2021
PSA 91Jun 12, 2019Jun 12, 2019

Recent recorded sales · PSA 7

DatePriceGradeSource
Aug 13, 2026$455.11PSA 7eBay
Jul 15, 2026$571.00PSA 7eBay
Jul 3, 2026$549.99PSA 7eBay
Dec 25, 2025$685.00PSA 7eBay
Dec 1, 2025$550.00PSA 7eBay
Oct 23, 2025$849.99PSA 7eBay
Sep 15, 2025$500.00PSA 7eBay
Sep 9, 2025$390.00PSA 7eBay
Aug 18, 2025$315.31PSA 7eBay
Jul 23, 2025$425.00PSA 7eBay
Jul 7, 2025$443.99PSA 7eBay
Jun 22, 2025$428.22PSA 7Goldin
May 31, 2025$274.99PSA 7eBay
May 29, 2025$499.99PSA 7eBay
May 11, 2025$500.00PSA 7eBay
Mar 15, 2025$599.95PSA 7eBay
Feb 10, 2025$425.00PSA 7Fanatics Collect
Jan 29, 2025$675.00PSA 7eBay
Nov 17, 2024$499.95PSA 7eBay
Oct 6, 2024$490.55PSA 7eBay

Open the full price history and chart