2026 Topps 1991 card values

MAZIDEX tracks 164 2026 Topps 1991 cards with recorded sales. The most valuable is the Jacob Misiorowski #T91-74 at about $330.00 in PSA 10, from 3 sales in the last 90 days. 144 cards have a current value. Values come from completed sales only, grade by grade, never from asking prices.

Most valuable 2026 Topps 1991 cards

CardGradeValueTypical rangeSales, 90 days
Jacob Misiorowski #T91-74PSA 10$330.00$327.50–$390.003
Shohei Ohtani #T91-100 Koi FishRAW$65.00$49.56–$78.509
Cam Schlittler #T91-86 Crackleboard FoilPSA 9$41.51$40.76–$43.004
Cam Schlittler #T91-86PSA 9$33.50$29.02–$37.735
Shohei Ohtani #T91-100PSA 8$29.61$27.31–$30.813
Cam Schlittler #T91-86 Koi FishRAW$21.25$16.75–$23.376
Roman Anthony #T91-71 Koi FishRAW$16.99$15.00–$18.005
Shohei Ohtani #T91-100 PinkRAW$16.95$15.00–$20.005
Roman Anthony #T91-71PSA 9$15.59$14.17–$22.803
Jacob Misiorowski #T91-74 Crackleboard FoilRAW$13.01$10.99–$15.0013
Jacob Misiorowski #T91-74 PinkRAW$11.99$9.99–$13.2316
Shohei Ohtani #T91-100 Crackleboard FoilRAW$11.95$9.50–$12.6011
Cam Schlittler #T91-86 PinkRAW$11.75$9.39–$13.494
Aaron Judge #T91-34 Koi FishRAW$9.00$9.00–$11.504
Yoshinobu Yamamoto #T91-55 Koi FishRAW$7.50$6.62–$12.5012
Kirby Puckett #T91-94 Koi FishRAW$7.01$6.51–$7.393
Nolan Ryan #T91-97 PinkRAW$6.25$5.49–$6.624
Roman Anthony #T91-71 PinkRAW$5.51$3.89–$8.497
Roman Anthony #T91-71 Crackleboard FoilRAW$5.49$4.25–$6.527
Mickey Mantle #T91-48 PinkRAW$5.49$5.00–$5.995
Derek Jeter #T91-30 Koi FishRAW$5.38$3.95–$6.624
Pete Crow-Armstrong #T91-64 Crackleboard FoilRAW$3.25$2.50–$3.9912
Paul Skenes #T91-50 Crackleboard FoilRAW$3.25$2.56–$3.754
Shoeless Joe Jackson #T91-27 Crackleboard FoilRAW$3.00$2.00–$3.006
Derek Jeter #T91-30 Crackleboard FoilRAW$3.00$2.35–$3.873
Ken Griffey Jr. #T91-45 Crackleboard FoilRAW$2.99$2.36–$3.757
Jac Caglianone #T91-42 Crackleboard FoilRAW$2.94$2.52–$3.329
Mickey Mantle #T91-48 Crackleboard FoilRAW$2.61$2.02–$3.6015
Roberto Clemente #T91-99 Crackleboard FoilRAW$2.50$1.75–$3.064
Cole Young #T91-98 Crackleboard FoilRAW$2.49$1.74–$3.243
Bobby Witt Jr. #T91-3 Crackleboard FoilRAW$2.48$2.06–$2.926
Nolan Ryan #T91-97 Crackleboard FoilRAW$2.38$2.06–$2.886
Aaron Judge #T91-34 Crackleboard FoilRAW$2.25$1.99–$3.259
Nolan McLean #T91-63 Crackleboard FoilRAW$2.25$2.12–$2.997
Pete Alonso #T91-12 Koi FishRAW$2.13$2.00–$2.694
Don Mattingly #T91-68 Crackleboard FoilRAW$2.00$1.95–$2.139
Bo Jackson #T91-29 Crackleboard FoilRAW$1.99$1.99–$2.995
Albert Pujols #T91-43 Crackleboard FoilRAW$1.99$1.59–$1.993
Chase Burns #T91-73RAW$1.97$1.22–$2.2811
Aaron Judge #T91-34RAW$1.90$1.64–$2.0022
Yoshinobu Yamamoto #T91-55 Crackleboard FoilRAW$1.87$1.44–$2.258
Mickey Mantle #T91-48RAW$1.81$1.12–$2.2439
David Wright #T91-66RAW$1.80$0.99–$1.887
Will Clark #T91-11 Crackleboard FoilRAW$1.79$1.59–$1.834
Chase Burns #T91-73 Crackleboard FoilRAW$1.79$1.39–$2.023
Tarik Skubal #T91-79 Crackleboard FoilRAW$1.77$1.38–$2.013
Pete Crow-Armstrong #T91-64RAW$1.75$1.34–$2.1830
Don Mattingly #T91-68RAW$1.75$1.49–$1.9926
Aaron Judge #T91-34 The Real OneRAW$1.75$1.00–$1.999
Didier Fuentes #T91-76 Crackleboard FoilRAW$1.75$1.08–$1.873

Each value is that grade's median daily sale price over the last 90 days; the typical range is the middle half of those days. A card shows its most valuable grade with a current value.

Players in 2026 Topps 1991