MAZIDEX

1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258

1989 Fleer · #258

What is the 1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 worth?

Estimated value in PSA 10: $41.50, typically $40.75–$43.00, from 4 recorded sales in the last 90 days; most recently Sep 30, 2026.

24 recorded sales in this grade in all, from $26.00 to $67.00.

Every price on this page is an actual recorded transaction, not an asking price. Raw and graded sales are kept separate, and each sale links to its receipt. How MAZIDEX values cards.

Updated with sales through Sep 30, 2026.

Recorded sales by grade

GradeRecorded salesFirst recordedMost recent
PSA 1024Jul 16, 2025Sep 30, 2026
RAW21Jul 12, 2026Sep 24, 2026
PSA 920Jun 18, 2023Sep 24, 2026
PSA 817Mar 2, 2023Jul 22, 2026
SGC 92Apr 7, 2024May 4, 2024
PSA 72Jan 4, 2024Jan 9, 2024
SGC 81Jun 27, 2025Jun 27, 2025
CGC 8.51Jun 25, 2025Jun 25, 2025
SGC 8.51Feb 2, 2025Feb 2, 2025
CGC 81Jul 19, 2024Jul 19, 2024
CGC 9.51Apr 22, 2024Apr 22, 2024
PSA 61May 10, 2023May 10, 2023

Recent recorded sales · PSA 10

DatePriceGradeSource
Sep 30, 2026$39.99PSA 10eBay
Sep 23, 2026$46.00PSA 10eBay
Sep 16, 2026$41.00PSA 10eBay
Sep 2, 2026$42.00PSA 10eBay
Jul 29, 2026$44.99PSA 10eBay
Jul 20, 2026$50.00PSA 10eBay
Jul 15, 2026$44.99PSA 10eBay
Jul 1, 2026$49.51PSA 10eBay
Dec 31, 2025$61.00PSA 10eBay
Dec 17, 2025$49.99PSA 10eBay
Dec 8, 2025$48.95PSA 10eBay
Dec 3, 2025$49.99PSA 10eBay
Nov 19, 2025$65.00PSA 10eBay
Nov 5, 2025$67.00PSA 10eBay
Oct 22, 2025$32.00PSA 10eBay
Oct 9, 2025$29.99PSA 10eBay
Sep 10, 2025$31.99PSA 10eBay
Aug 28, 2025$49.00PSA 10eBay
Aug 27, 2025$31.00PSA 10eBay
Aug 13, 2025$30.99PSA 10eBay

Open the full price history and chart