MAZIDEX

1958 Topps Sherm Lollar #491 All Star

1958 Topps · #491 · All Star

What is the 1958 Topps Sherm Lollar #491 All Star worth?

Estimated value in RAW: $3.50, typically $2.65–$3.80, from 4 recorded sales in the last 90 days; most recently Sep 28, 2026.

11 recorded sales in this grade in all, from $1.07 to $20.00.

Every price on this page is an actual recorded transaction, not an asking price. Raw and graded sales are kept separate, and each sale links to its receipt. How MAZIDEX values cards.

Updated with sales through Sep 28, 2026.

Recorded sales by grade

GradeRecorded salesFirst recordedMost recent
RAW11Dec 25, 2025Sep 28, 2026
PSA 611May 1, 2023Nov 11, 2025
PSA 78Feb 16, 2023Dec 18, 2025
PSA 58Jan 12, 2023May 17, 2025
PSA 36Apr 5, 2024May 25, 2026
SGC 55May 9, 2024Apr 2, 2025
PSA 84Mar 1, 2023Aug 5, 2025
SGC 64Apr 21, 2024Mar 11, 2025
PSA 43May 25, 2024Jan 20, 2025
PSA 1.52Jan 5, 2023Jul 27, 2026
SGC 6.52Mar 22, 2024Aug 29, 2025
SGC 82Nov 28, 2024Mar 12, 2025
PSA 91Feb 8, 2026Feb 8, 2026
PSA 4.51Dec 23, 2024Dec 23, 2024
PSA 21Dec 1, 2024Dec 1, 2024

Recent recorded sales · RAW

DatePriceGradeSource
Sep 28, 2026$6.50RAWeBay
Sep 28, 2026$1.69RAWeBay
Sep 16, 2026$3.50RAWeBay
Aug 30, 2026$1.80RAWeBay
Aug 5, 2026$4.00RAWeBay
Aug 1, 2026$5.50RAWeBay
Jul 12, 2026$5.50RAWeBay
Jul 10, 2026$20.00RAWeBay
Dec 30, 2025$3.00RAWeBay
Dec 30, 2025$1.07RAWeBay
Dec 25, 2025$8.00RAWeBay

Open the full price history and chart