1991 Pro Set card values

MAZIDEX tracks 130 1991 Pro Set cards with recorded sales. The most valuable is the Bill Belichick #126 at about $223.50 in PSA 10, from 5 sales in the last 90 days. 58 cards have a current value. Values come from completed sales only, grade by grade, never from asking prices.

Most valuable 1991 Pro Set cards

CardGradeValueTypical rangeSales, 90 days
Bill Belichick #126PSA 10$223.50$212.50–$234.505
Emmitt Smith #1 Offensive RoyPSA 10$82.48$70.74–$94.233
Brett Favre #762PSA 9$22.76$21.00–$28.384
John Randle #835RAW$9.99$9.99–$9.9915
Derrick Thomas #19 Error Bills Helmet on FrontRAW$5.49$3.74–$7.994
Tom Waddle #818RAW$2.17$1.33–$3.034
Barry Sanders #39RAW$2.00$1.60–$2.005
WARREN MOON #370RAW$1.99$1.75–$2.569
Dan Marino #726RAW$1.99$1.12–$1.997
Jim Thorpe #3 Pioneer of the GameRAW$1.98$1.94–$1.993
Jerry Rice #379RAW$1.89$1.24–$1.957
Barry Sanders #502RAW$1.80$1.33–$1.996
Jerry Rice #11RAW$1.79$1.19–$1.997
Dan Marino #25RAW$1.65$1.26–$1.7911
Mike Ditka #108RAW$1.62$1.59–$1.6630
Jerry Glanville #99RAW$1.59$1.29–$1.793
Don Shula #216RAW$1.57$0.99–$1.595
Bo Jackson #42RAW$1.52$1.06–$1.835
Steve Young #296RAW$1.50$1.00–$1.505
Lawrence Taylor #602RAW$1.50$1.25–$1.603
Barry Sanders #10RAW$1.50$1.37–$1.9910
Paul Brown #5RAW$1.50$1.25–$1.753
Raghib Ismail #36RAW$1.49$0.99–$2.0022
Howie Long #191RAW$1.49$0.99–$2.006
Otto Graham #4RAW$1.49$1.00–$1.757
Ty Detmer #37RAW$1.49$1.49–$1.543
John Elway #138RAW$1.49$1.24–$1.594
Jimmy Johnson #405RAW$1.44$1.22–$1.649
Terry Allen #833RAW$1.42$0.88–$1.858
Emmitt Smith #485RAW$1.40$0.90–$1.7213
Emmitt Smith #1RAW$1.40$0.99–$1.774
Joe Montana #653RAW$1.38$0.99–$1.549
Lawrence Taylor #394RAW$1.36$0.99–$1.395
Earl Campbell #27RAW$1.34$1.15–$1.575
Aeneas Williams #788RAW$1.32$1.16–$1.483
Eric Dickerson #175RAW$1.29$0.95–$1.493
Joe Montana #3RAW$1.29$1.04–$1.556
Bill Parcells #72RAW$1.25$0.99–$1.406
Barry Sanders #388RAW$1.25$1.18–$1.608
Art McNally #352RAW$1.25$1.12–$1.383
Dan Marino #210RAW$1.25$0.99–$1.799
Bo Jackson #335 Barry SandersRAW$1.24$0.99–$1.625
Emmitt Smith #1 GazetteRAW$1.21$0.99–$1.444
Joe Montana #387RAW$1.09$1.00–$1.368
Derrick Thomas #19RAW$1.00$0.99–$2.005
Joe Gibbs #324RAW$1.00$0.99–$1.596
Marv Levy #90RAW$0.99$0.85–$0.993
Dan Reeves #144RAW$0.99$0.99–$1.193
Mike Singletary #396RAW$0.99$0.99–$1.124
Thurman Thomas #86RAW$0.99$0.55–$0.993

Each value is that grade's median daily sale price over the last 90 days; the typical range is the middle half of those days. A card shows its most valuable grade with a current value.

Players in 1991 Pro Set