1958 Topps card values

MAZIDEX tracks 53 1958 Topps cards with recorded sales. The most valuable is the Jim Brown #62 at about $7,106 in PSA 7, from 8 sales in the last 90 days. 50 cards have a current value. Values come from completed sales only, grade by grade, never from asking prices.

Most valuable 1958 Topps cards

CardGradeValueTypical rangeSales, 90 days
Jim Brown #62PSA 7$7,106$6,335–$7,8758
Bart Starr #66PSA 8$1,020$972.50–$1,0213
Sonny Jurgensen #90PSA 7$292.48$277.50–$299.964
Frank Gifford #73PSA 4$33.50$30.25–$35.254
George Blanda #129RAW$9.63$7.36–$12.1330
Raymond Berry #120RAW$9.50$5.82–$12.5630
Bobby Layne #2RAW$9.47$7.15–$11.1530
Cleveland Browns #9RAW$8.50$5.95–$14.1130
Lenny Moore #10RAW$8.00$4.67–$10.6430
Chuck Bednarik #35RAW$7.10$5.44–$9.4930
Art Donovan #106RAW$6.22$3.99–$7.6227
Lou Groza #52RAW$5.00$4.25–$6.9325
Baltimore Colts #110RAW$4.50$2.75–$6.2421
Green Bay Packers #96RAW$4.31$3.06–$7.6319
Gino Marchetti #16RAW$4.25$3.25–$5.5323
Ollie Matson #127RAW$4.25$3.25–$7.1830
Ron Kramer #58RAW$4.25$3.51–$5.5025
Milt Plum #5RAW$4.25$2.88–$5.5026
Babe Parilli #118RAW$4.12$2.38–$5.3522
Eddie LeBaron #112RAW$4.00$2.87–$5.6325
San Francisco 49ers #41RAW$4.00$2.25–$5.5921
Lamar McHan #68RAW$4.00$3.01–$6.7627
Leo Nomellini #89RAW$3.70$2.46–$4.2924
Les Richter #105RAW$3.66$2.25–$8.5017
Chicago Cardinals #69RAW$3.63$2.25–$4.0317
Jim Doran #43RAW$3.54$2.30–$4.5316
Alan Ameche #12RAW$3.50$2.75–$5.7525
Yale Lary #18RAW$3.50$2.71–$5.8229
Howard Cassady #7RAW$3.31$2.59–$6.0023
Lou Creekmur #81RAW$3.29$2.14–$4.2520
New York Giants #61RAW$3.27$2.37–$4.3825
Dick Deschaine #48RAW$3.25$2.26–$4.2518
Jim Ringo #103RAW$3.25$2.13–$4.8628
Bobby Dillon #32RAW$3.25$2.62–$6.1720
Charley Conerly #84RAW$3.13$2.33–$3.4620
Philadelphia Eagles #109RAW$3.12$2.14–$3.5918
Hugh McElhenny #122RAW$3.01$2.27–$4.3923
Jim David #13RAW$3.01$2.19–$4.8214
Andy Robustelli #15RAW$3.00$2.09–$6.7521
Roosevelt Brown #102RAW$2.85$2.25–$5.2727
Gene Brito #113RAW$2.84$1.50–$4.2517
Dick Stanfel #39RAW$2.75$2.30–$4.0219
Tobin Rote #94RAW$2.75$2.13–$4.0020
Detroit Lions #115RAW$2.55$2.25–$4.7519
Jon Arnett #20RAW$2.50$2.25–$3.3419
Matt Hazeltine #100RAW$2.38$1.38–$3.7219
Los Angeles Rams #85RAW$2.25$1.72–$3.0022
Frank Varrichione #77RAW$2.15$0.94–$4.2522
Gene Filipski #1RAW$2.09$1.25–$2.6526
Jim Mutscheller #14RAW$1.95$1.19–$2.8417

Each value is that grade's median daily sale price over the last 90 days; the typical range is the middle half of those days. A card shows its most valuable grade with a current value.

Players in 1958 Topps