2026 Topps Series 2 1991 All-Stars card values

MAZIDEX tracks 58 2026 Topps Series 2 1991 All-Stars cards with recorded sales. The most valuable is the Shohei Ohtani #91AS-50 Crackle Foil at about $3.88 in RAW, from 22 sales in the last 90 days. 33 cards have a current value. Values come from completed sales only, grade by grade, never from asking prices.

Most valuable 2026 Topps Series 2 1991 All-Stars cards

CardGradeValueTypical rangeSales, 90 days
Shohei Ohtani #91AS-50 Crackle FoilRAW$3.88$2.15–$6.2522
Roberto Clemente #91AS-25RAW$3.14$2.07–$7.354
Buster Posey #91AS-18RAW$2.25$1.62–$6.123
Ken Griffey Jr. #91AS-35 Crackle FoilRAW$2.12$1.44–$2.9910
Aaron Judge #91AS-1RAW$1.99$1.21–$2.508
Aaron Judge #91AS-1 Crackle FoilRAW$1.99$1.06–$2.898
Pedro Martinez #91AS-8RAW$1.99$1.75–$2.005
Christian Yelich #91AS-16RAW$1.95$1.29–$3.134
Jackie Robinson #91AS-15RAW$1.89$1.37–$1.9510
Cal Ripken Jr. #91AS-29RAW$1.86$1.68–$1.933
Johnny Bench #91AS-47 Crackle FoilRAW$1.86$1.65–$2.063
Ken Griffey Jr. #91AS-35RAW$1.79$1.04–$1.9411
Pete Crow-Armstrong #91AS-46RAW$1.79$0.99–$2.0010
Buster Posey #91AS-18 Crackle FoilRAW$1.78$1.39–$1.893
Freddie Freeman #91AS-22RAW$1.77$1.69–$1.865
Ichiro #91AS-31RAW$1.74$1.72–$1.753
Mike Trout #91AS-4RAW$1.71$1.38–$1.934
Sandy Koufax #91AS-40RAW$1.64$1.15–$1.696
Tony Gwynn #91AS-6RAW$1.57$1.54–$1.624
George Brett #91AS-41RAW$1.50$1.35–$1.883
Mookie Betts #91AS-13RAW$1.50$1.49–$1.595
Shohei Ohtani #91AS-50RAW$1.49$1.35–$2.6911
Johnny Bench #91AS-47RAW$1.49$1.34–$1.738
Reggie Jackson #91AS-14RAW$1.49$1.24–$1.753
Ronald Acuna Jr. #91AS-28RAW$1.44$1.06–$1.804
Rickey Henderson #91AS-10RAW$1.42$1.25–$1.745
Julio Rodriguez #91AS-23RAW$1.39$1.34–$1.443
Hank Aaron #91AS-38RAW$1.34$0.78–$1.926
Bobby Witt Jr. #91AS-24RAW$1.25$1.12–$1.373
Bobby Witt Jr. #91AS-24 Crackle FoilRAW$1.23$1.04–$1.817
Randy Johnson #91AS-20RAW$1.03$1.00–$1.234
Paul Skenes #91AS-39RAW$1.00$0.99–$1.394
Juan Soto #91AS-34RAW$1.00$1.00–$1.503
Kirby Puckett #91AS-45RAWNot enough recent sales0
Elly De La Cruz #91AS-17RAWNot enough recent sales0
Clayton Kershaw #91AS-30RAWNot enough recent sales0
Derek Jeter #91AS-32RAWNot enough recent sales0
Kirby Puckett #91AS-45 Crackle FoilRAWNot enough recent sales0
Nolan Ryan #91AS-19RAWNot enough recent sales0
Bryce Harper #91AS-7RAWNot enough recent sales0
Kyle Schwarber #91AS-3RAWNot enough recent sales0
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. #91AS-37RAWNot enough recent sales0
Gunnar Henderson #91AS-49RAWNot enough recent sales0
James Wood #91AS-42RAWNot enough recent sales0
Sammy Sosa #91AS-5RAWNot enough recent sales0
Vladimir Guerrero #91AS-21RAWNot enough recent sales0
Albert Pujols #91AS-26RAWNot enough recent sales0
Fernando Tatis Jr. #91AS-36RAWNot enough recent sales0
Frank Thomas #91AS-33RAWNot enough recent sales0
Gerrit Cole #91AS-43RAWNot enough recent sales0

Each value is that grade's median daily sale price over the last 90 days; the typical range is the middle half of those days. A card shows its most valuable grade with a current value.

Players in 2026 Topps Series 2 1991 All-Stars