2025 Topps Update Mystical card values

MAZIDEX tracks 42 2025 Topps Update Mystical cards with recorded sales. The most valuable is the Shohei Ohtani #MYS-9 at about $225.00 in PSA 10, from 5 sales in the last 90 days. 30 cards have a current value. Values come from completed sales only, grade by grade, never from asking prices.

Most valuable 2025 Topps Update Mystical cards

CardGradeValueTypical rangeSales, 90 days
Shohei Ohtani #MYS-9PSA 10$225.00$203.00–$249.995
Nick Kurtz #MYS-17PSA 10$50.00$35.25–$90.003
Shohei Ohtani #MYS-9 PinkRAW$20.99$19.32–$26.2517
Bobby Witt Jr. #MYS-8 PinkRAW$3.99$3.99–$4.243
Paul Skenes #MYS-22RAW$3.80$2.88–$4.2465
Aaron Judge #MYS-18 PinkRAW$3.74$2.87–$4.744
Aaron Judge #MYS-18RAW$3.49$2.99–$4.00102
Ronald Acuna Jr. #MYS-11 PinkRAW$3.25$2.50–$4.603
Mike Trout #MYS-19 PinkRAW$2.61$2.43–$2.933
Ronald Acuna Jr. #MYS-11RAW$2.38$1.56–$2.7715
Juan Soto #MYS-14 PinkRAW$2.14$2.00–$2.384
Elly De La Cruz #MYS-5RAW$2.00$1.50–$2.4930
Bobby Witt Jr. #MYS-8RAW$1.85$1.45–$2.0030
Mike Trout #MYS-19RAW$1.79$1.49–$2.3835
Jacob Wilson #MYS-6RAW$1.75$1.25–$2.0624
Gunnar Henderson #MYS-2 PinkRAW$1.75$1.27–$1.877
Hyeseong Kim #MYS-23RAW$1.72$1.10–$2.1919
James Wood #MYS-1RAW$1.70$1.45–$2.4847
Kristian Campbell #MYS-12RAW$1.60$1.19–$1.7311
Bryce Harper #MYS-3RAW$1.50$1.12–$1.9430
Cam Smith #MYS-15RAW$1.50$1.12–$2.5019
Matt Shaw #MYS-16RAW$1.50$0.99–$2.5612
Dalton Rushing #MYS-13RAW$1.42$1.00–$1.9918
Cam Smith #MYS-15 PinkRAW$1.34$0.87–$1.774
Dylan Crews #MYS-20RAW$1.32$0.99–$1.9218
Juan Soto #MYS-14RAW$1.25$0.99–$1.6427
Gunnar Henderson #MYS-2RAW$1.25$1.00–$1.6511
Francisco Lindor #MYS-7RAW$1.00$0.99–$1.7815
Coby Mayo #MYS-25RAW$1.00$0.99–$1.7516
Luke Keaschall #MYS-21RAW$1.00$0.99–$1.2510
Paul Skenes #MYS-22 PinkRAWNot enough recent sales0
Bryce Harper #MYS-3 PinkRAWNot enough recent sales0
Elly De La Cruz #MYS-5 PinkRAWNot enough recent sales0
Jacob Wilson #MYS-6 PinkRAWNot enough recent sales0
Coby Mayo #MYS-25 PinkRAWNot enough recent sales0
Dalton Rushing #MYS-13 GreenRAWNot enough recent sales0
Luisangel Acuna #MYS-4 PinkRAWNot enough recent sales0
Dalton Rushing #MYS-13 PinkRAWNot enough recent sales0
Fernando Tatis Jr. #MYS-10 PinkRAWNot enough recent sales0
Hyeseong Kim #MYS-23 PinkRAWNot enough recent sales0
Kristian Campbell #MYS-12 PinkRAWNot enough recent sales0
Nick Kurtz #MYS-17 PinkRAWNot enough recent sales0

Each value is that grade's median daily sale price over the last 90 days; the typical range is the middle half of those days. A card shows its most valuable grade with a current value.

Players in 2025 Topps Update Mystical