The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes card values

MAZIDEX tracks 127 The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes cards with recorded sales. The most valuable is the 2025 Topps Royalty WWE Superior Signature #SUP-NCR Blue at about $259.99 in RAW, from 3 sales in the last 90 days. 9 cards have a current value. Values come from completed sales only, grade by grade, never from asking prices.

Most valuable The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes cards

CardGradeValueTypical rangeSales, 90 days
2025 Topps Royalty WWE Superior Signature #SUP-NCR BlueRAW$259.99$211.25–$261.773
2024 Panini Three Count WWE Downtown #18RAW$125.50$110.00–$136.257
2026 Topps Universe WWE Superstar Triple Relic #STR-CRRAW$14.00$10.50–$15.0020
2024 Panini Prizm WWE #132 SilverRAW$7.99$4.49–$9.003
2025 Topps Chrome WWE #1 X-FractorRAW$2.99$2.49–$3.003
2026 Topps Universe WWE Namesakes #NS-20RAW$2.67$1.99–$2.9913
2026 Topps Cosmic Chrome WWE #1RAW$1.80$1.29–$1.895
2026 Topps Chrome WWE #21RAW$1.53$0.99–$1.999
2026 Topps Chrome WWE #21 X-FractorRAW$1.49$1.25–$1.505
2023 Panini Prizm WWE #1 Ruby WaveRAWNot enough recent sales0
2025 Topps Chrome WWE #1 Speckle RefractorRAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Panini Chronicles WWE #385RAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Panini Prizm WWE #1 IceRAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Panini Revolution WWE #17 AstroRAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Panini Select WWE Sensations #15 SilverRAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Panini Select WWE #28 Light BlueRAWNot enough recent sales0
2025 Topps Chrome WWE #1 Neon Green Black RefractorRAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Panini Chronicles WWE #175 BronzeRAWNot enough recent sales0
2024 Panini Prizm WWE #132 Under CardRAWNot enough recent sales0
2024 Panini Select WWE #24 Silver PrizmRAWNot enough recent sales0
2025 Topps Chrome WWE Marks of Champions Autograph #MOC-CRRAWNot enough recent sales0
2025 Topps Chrome WWE #1 Teal Laser RefractorRAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Panini Chronicles WWE #223RAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Panini Prizm WWE #1 SilverRAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Panini Select WWE #28 Orange FlashRAWNot enough recent sales0
2024 Panini Prizm WWE #132 GreenRAWNot enough recent sales0
2025 Topps Chrome WWE #1 Red Blue RefractorRAWNot enough recent sales0
2022 Panini Impeccable WWE #42RAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Panini Chronicles WWE #255 BronzeRAWNot enough recent sales0
2024 Panini National Treasures WWE #2RAWNot enough recent sales0

Each value is that grade's median daily sale price over the last 90 days; the typical range is the middle half of those days. A card shows its most valuable grade with a current value.

The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes sets