Matthew Schaefer card values

MAZIDEX tracks 110 Matthew Schaefer cards with recorded sales. The most valuable is the 2025 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autograph #R-MS Cosmic at about $1,450 in RAW, from 3 sales in the last 90 days. 97 cards have a current value. Values come from completed sales only, grade by grade, never from asking prices.

Most valuable Matthew Schaefer cards

CardGradeValueTypical rangeSales, 90 days
2025 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autograph #R-MS CosmicRAW$1,450$1,430–$1,5163
2025 O-Pee-Chee Platinum #268 Seismic GoldRAW$1,035$795.00–$1,1395
2025 Upper Deck Series 2 #451PSA 10$825.00$767.91–$883.3841
2025 Upper Deck Series 2 #451 Outburst SilverRAW$710.10$636.56–$777.656
2025 SP Authentic Pageantry Autograph #P-7RAW$430.24$390.14–$466.577
2024 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors #25 Autograph PatchRAW$250.00$202.75–$294.174
2024 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors #69 Autograph PatchRAW$234.31$199.02–$265.584
2025 Upper Deck Extended Series UD Canvas #C-365PSA 9$220.00$206.29–$247.484
2025 Upper Deck Series 2 #451 HolidayRAW$179.06$157.25–$188.226
2025 Upper Deck Clear Cut Canvas Rookie Debut #CD-MSRAW$140.00$115.38–$160.1730
2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow #CF-MS Yellow Green Extended RookiePSA 10$130.63$119.35–$136.513
2025 Upper Deck Allure #AR-MS Extended RookiePSA 10$120.00$100.00–$125.9915
2025 Upper Deck Series 2 UD Portraits #P-32PSA 10$107.44$93.66–$121.223
2025 Fleer Ultra Rising Stars #RS-21 GoldPSA 9$86.01$79.01–$92.504
2025 Flair Wave of the Future #WF-9RAW$85.00$62.94–$99.9914
2025 Flair #194PSA 9$84.38$67.20–$87.693
2025 Upper Deck Ice Showmen #SM-25RAW$74.99$61.71–$95.0030
2025 Upper Deck Ice Black #BI-33RAW$74.00$55.50–$95.7521
2025 Upper Deck Ice Premieres Jersey #IPJ-MSRAW$65.00$56.65–$75.1225
2025 Fleer Ultra #164 GoldRAW$62.64$54.75–$75.669
2025 Fleer Ultra #164PSA 9$61.45$50.37–$86.253
2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Slaps #SL-13PSA 10$61.00$53.70–$65.503
2025 Upper Deck Star Rookies #5PSA 9$59.00$41.04–$60.505
2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow #CF-MS Extended Rookie Red OrangePSA 9$57.44$53.69–$73.263
2025 O-Pee-Chee Platinum #268 Neon Yellow SurgeRAW$55.97$44.31–$65.0012
2025 Upper Deck Ice Cool Threads #CT-MARAW$52.50$44.28–$71.2514
2025 O-Pee-Chee Platinum #268 Pink MagmaRAW$51.00$39.55–$60.8813
2025 Upper Deck Ice Cool Threads #CT-MA PatchRAW$51.00$45.77–$54.754
2025 O-Pee-Chee Platinum #268 SunsetRAW$49.00$43.75–$64.5622
2025 Upper Deck Series 2 UD Canvas #C-259 Program of ExcellenceRAW$42.57$41.13–$45.389

Each value is that grade's median daily sale price over the last 90 days; the typical range is the middle half of those days. A card shows its most valuable grade with a current value.

Matthew Schaefer sets