Christy Mathewson card values

MAZIDEX tracks 40 Christy Mathewson cards with recorded sales. The most valuable is the 2026 Topps Series 2 All Aces #AA-14 at about $122.50 in RAW, from 10 sales in the last 90 days. 14 cards have a current value. Values come from completed sales only, grade by grade, never from asking prices.

Most valuable Christy Mathewson cards

CardGradeValueTypical rangeSales, 90 days
2026 Topps Series 2 All Aces #AA-14RAW$122.50$108.13–$137.5710
2023 Topps Living #666RAW$6.99$6.99–$6.9915
2025 Topps Chrome Platinum #498 Green Vibrations RefractorRAW$6.99$4.62–$7.993
1960 Fleer #2RAW$5.50$3.95–$8.5030
2023 Topps All Aces #AA-35RAW$5.25$4.96–$6.8760
1961 Fleer #59RAW$4.76$3.50–$7.5028
2025 Topps Chrome Platinum #498 Topps RefractorRAW$3.07$2.74–$3.369
2025 Topps Chrome Platinum #498 Blue PrismRAW$2.35$1.75–$2.774
2025 Topps Chrome Platinum #498 PrismRAW$1.99$1.75–$2.124
2025 Topps Chrome Platinum #498RAW$1.70$1.38–$1.9410
2026 Topps Series 2 1991 #91B2-31RAW$1.62$0.99–$1.838
2025 Topps Allen and Ginter Wicked Curves #WC-38RAW$1.50$1.18–$1.8410
2025 Topps Chrome Platinum #498 RefractorRAW$1.50$1.00–$2.144
2025 Topps Allen and Ginter #7RAW$1.35$0.93–$1.508
2024 Topps Update Autumn Tales #AT-27RAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Stadium Club #194RAWNot enough recent sales0
2022 Topps Pristine #10 RefractorRAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Topps All Aces #AA-35 BlueRAWNot enough recent sales0
2023 Topps All Aces #AA-35 BlackRAWNot enough recent sales0
2024 Topps Stadium Club #169 RedRAWNot enough recent sales0
2019 Topps Archives #165RAWNot enough recent sales0
2019 Stadium Club #29RAWNot enough recent sales0
2022 Topps Update Diamond Greats Die Cuts #DGDC-64RAWNot enough recent sales0
2024 Topps Grand Gamers #GOG-23RAWNot enough recent sales0
2024 Topps Stadium Club #169RAWNot enough recent sales0
2022 Topps Update #US102 SP VariationRAWNot enough recent sales0
2024 Topps Stadium Club #169 Chrome RefractorRAWNot enough recent sales0
2021 Topps Archives #148RAWNot enough recent sales0
2024 Topps Update Autumn Tales #AT-27 BlueRAWNot enough recent sales0
2024 Topps Stadium Club #169 ChromeRAWNot enough recent sales0

Each value is that grade's median daily sale price over the last 90 days; the typical range is the middle half of those days. A card shows its most valuable grade with a current value.

Christy Mathewson sets