MAZIDEX

1959 Topps Hugh McElhenny #5

1959 Topps · #5

What is the 1959 Topps Hugh McElhenny #5 worth?

Estimated value in RAW: $4.99, typically $2.44–$8.50, from 24 recorded sales in the last 90 days; most recently Oct 31, 2026.

30 recorded sales in this grade in all, from $0.79 to $17.50.

Every price on this page is an actual recorded transaction, not an asking price. Raw and graded sales are kept separate, and each sale links to its receipt. How MAZIDEX values cards.

Updated with sales through Oct 31, 2026.

Recorded sales by grade

GradeRecorded salesFirst recordedMost recent
RAW30Jul 22, 2026Oct 31, 2026
PSA 825Dec 24, 2021Oct 15, 2026
PSA 721Feb 2, 2021Aug 17, 2026
PSA 68Oct 7, 2021Dec 31, 2025
PSA 96Aug 6, 2017Jul 3, 2026
PSA 43Dec 11, 2021May 9, 2025
PSA 8.52Jun 20, 2025Sep 4, 2026
PSA 7.52Oct 29, 2021Aug 13, 2025
PSA 52Apr 6, 2021Oct 21, 2023
SGC 61Jan 22, 2025Jan 22, 2025
SGC 71Dec 26, 2024Dec 26, 2024
CGC 61Apr 10, 2024Apr 10, 2024
SGC 41Feb 17, 2021Feb 17, 2021
PSA 101Nov 16, 2016Nov 16, 2016

Recent recorded sales · RAW

DatePriceGradeSource
Oct 31, 2026$1.84RAWeBay
Oct 30, 2026$1.00RAWeBay
Oct 25, 2026$2.49RAWeBay
Oct 22, 2026$17.50RAWeBay
Oct 20, 2026$10.00RAWeBay
Oct 19, 2026$1.76RAWeBay
Oct 17, 2026$12.50RAWeBay
Oct 15, 2026$2.49RAWeBay
Oct 14, 2026$6.00RAWeBay
Oct 12, 2026$4.99RAWeBay
Oct 9, 2026$10.00RAWeBay
Oct 9, 2026$6.00RAWeBay
Oct 3, 2026$1.34RAWeBay
Sep 24, 2026$6.00RAWeBay
Sep 19, 2026$4.25RAWeBay
Sep 19, 2026$0.79RAWeBay
Sep 16, 2026$8.50RAWeBay
Sep 2, 2026$4.50RAWeBay
Aug 29, 2026$0.79RAWeBay
Aug 29, 2026$2.30RAWeBay

Open the full price history and chart