MAZIDEX

1960 Topps Eddie Mathews #558 All Star

1960 Topps · #558 · All Star

23 recorded sales in PSA 7, from $57.00 to $150.00, most recently Sep 25, 2026.

Every price on this page is an actual recorded transaction, not an asking price. Raw and graded sales are kept separate, and each sale links to its receipt. How MAZIDEX values cards.

Updated with sales through Sep 25, 2026.

Recorded sales by grade

GradeRecorded salesFirst recordedMost recent
PSA 723Nov 14, 2021Sep 25, 2026
PSA 519Jan 8, 2024Oct 31, 2025
PSA 819Mar 23, 2023Oct 13, 2025
PSA 618May 7, 2024Sep 4, 2026
PSA 415Sep 8, 2024Sep 6, 2026
RAW15Jul 10, 2026Sep 5, 2026
SGC 46Jul 29, 2024Jul 7, 2026
PSA 36Mar 28, 2023Dec 2, 2025
SGC 56Apr 14, 2024Jul 31, 2025
PSA 25May 10, 2023Jul 1, 2026
SGC 4.54Dec 10, 2024Aug 4, 2026
SGC 1.53Dec 15, 2024Dec 14, 2025
SGC 73Jan 19, 2025Dec 10, 2025
SGC 63Jun 3, 2024Sep 8, 2025
SGC 5.52Jun 3, 2024Aug 19, 2024
BVG 6.52Sep 12, 2016Sep 12, 2019
BVG 82Dec 17, 2014Apr 11, 2019
SGC 11Sep 9, 2025Sep 9, 2025
PSA 2.51Jul 22, 2025Jul 22, 2025
SGC 3.51Feb 13, 2025Feb 13, 2025
SGC 6.51Nov 5, 2024Nov 5, 2024
SGC 81Apr 30, 2024Apr 30, 2024
CSG 5.51May 12, 2023May 12, 2023
BVG 61Jul 17, 2022Jul 17, 2022
BVG 31Mar 15, 2021Mar 15, 2021
BVG 71Nov 14, 2017Nov 14, 2017
BVG 41Feb 9, 2016Feb 9, 2016

Recent recorded sales · PSA 7

DatePriceGradeSource
Sep 25, 2026$135.00PSA 7eBay
Jul 27, 2026$115.50PSA 7eBay
Jul 4, 2026$96.00PSA 7eBay
Jul 4, 2026$100.00PSA 7eBay
Nov 27, 2025$88.00PSA 7eBay
Sep 29, 2025$130.00PSA 7eBay
Sep 24, 2025$78.16PSA 7eBay
Aug 13, 2025$105.00PSA 7eBay
Jul 17, 2025$76.09PSA 7eBay
Jul 11, 2025$98.21PSA 7eBay
Jun 19, 2025$79.51PSA 7eBay
Jun 1, 2025$57.00PSA 7eBay
Apr 15, 2025$69.70PSA 7eBay
Jan 11, 2025$114.89PSA 7eBay
Jan 8, 2025$94.00PSA 7eBay
Dec 12, 2024$100.00PSA 7eBay
Dec 5, 2024$129.99PSA 7eBay
Oct 30, 2024$77.87PSA 7eBay
Jul 16, 2024$96.55PSA 7eBay
Jun 15, 2024$92.85PSA 7eBay

Open the full price history and chart